Being a big fan of gangster movies Carlito’s Way has long found residence on my IMDB watch list. Director Brian De Palma was responsible for Scarface, one of if not the greatest gangster film ever produced, alongside a whole array of films including The Untouchables and Mission: Impossible, so I was hopeful Carlito’s Way would follow suit. I was however sadly disappointed.
If you’re not familiar with the film it follows an ex-criminal (Al Pacino) who gets released five years into thirty year jail sentence. Feeling like he’s been given a new lease of life, an opportunity to start a fresh, he tries to avoid the vices of his previous life but his reputation in the business and the pressure from friends threaten his quest. The storyline sounded legitimate enough and with the cast and director behind it, I was pumped to watch, but from the offset I couldn’t help but dislike.
One of my biggest jibes was the acting. Sean Penn and Al Pacino have had their day and on that day they were top draw actors but Pacino has long been stuck in some postnatal, post-Scarface state that forces him to portray the same character in everything. Fair enough the accent was different but if I hadn’t of known better, I could’ve easily made the assumption Carlito was a post Godfather II Michael Corleone or Tony Montana at his peak, his range of portrayals hardly stretches the imagination. Pacino also gives me the impression that he’s drunk out of his mind in half of his scenes as he sarcastically shouts his lines out. Luis Guzman also bares the brunt of my disappointment, I mean Luis Guzman, the guy that often plays the role of a clumsy oaf not a hardcore criminal, his whole performance was massively disappointing alongside the majority of the cast bar Johnny Leguizamo, who I thought was refreshing and brought some well needed gangster grit to the film.
But you can’t entirely blame the cast, the script comes up with some beautiful moments, “Charlie, where’s my cheesecake?!” was my personal favourite.
The picture above summaries to me how ridiculous Carlito’s Way gets. This guy used to be a legend in the criminal underworld yet he panics about getting his hair wet so much that he’s forced to use a dustbin lid to shield his hair. To even think the lid is going to offer any substantial protection from the rain is ridiculous, to actually go and do it is even more so.
Fortunately the film starts to pick up halfway through where this legendary character starts showing some of his past graphic lifestyle, what I tuned in for, with Penn largely contributing to this upheaval as the story takes a turn away from a series of soppy dramas between Pacino and an ex-lover. However the ending brings us all crashing back down to earth with a comical catch the pigeon esque chase.
Overall the film takes itself far too seriously, this legendary character Carlito seems too weak to carry the storyline as I was never led to truly believe his character used to be this kingpin. The story’s premise is also rather weak, boiling down to a simple waiting game as Carlito accumulates his $75,000, not the most exciting idea to base the storyline on, especially as Carlito’s desperation and desire to accumulate the amount is never built up. Some films pass by at ease whilst Carlito’s Way drags you by your bollocks over a gigantic cheese grater, the film didn’t feel adventurous nor exciting and I was constantly waiting for the film to actually begin.
4/10